I read all the reviews saying "this is a cheap, high quality watch", and kind of wrote it off, it was cheap enough that I thought I'd give Stuhrling a try.
Everything, from the packaging, to the presentation in the box, to the intricate detail on the face and the band, was impeccable. The watch comes nicely layed out and discreetly strapped in, inside a beautiful wooden box. The inside of the case is very clean and high quality. It comes with it's own warranty card, cleaning cloth, and other info. I got a watch from MVMT before this for ~$150, and it was significantly worse than this. Both watches are beautiful, but Sturhling definitely has high quality all around, better prices, and better shipping.
If I could give it 6/5 stars, I would. I will definitely be buying from here again.